Medtronic 2090 Carelink Programmer Improper Restriction of Communication Channel to Intended Endpoints

CVE-2018-10596

Assigned byThe organization (CNA) that assigned this CVE ID and published the record, usually the vendor.
ICS-CERT (opens in new tab)
Published
Last modified
NVD status
Modified
CVSS 3.08High

Description

Medtronic 2090 CareLink Programmer

uses a virtual private network connection to securely download updates. It does not verify it is still connected to this virtual private network before downloading updates. The affected products initially establish an encapsulated IP-based VPN connection to a Medtronic-hosted update network. Once the VPN is established, it makes a request to a HTTP (non-TLS) server across the VPN for updates, which responds and provides any available updates. The programmer-side (client) service responsible for this HTTP request does not check to ensure it is still connected to the VPN before making the HTTP request. Thus, an attacker could cause the VPN connection to terminate (through various methods and attack points) and intercept the HTTP request, responding with malicious updates via a man-in-the-middle attack. The affected products do not verify the origin or integrity of these updates, as it insufficiently relied on the security of the VPN. An attacker with remote network access to the programmer could influence these communications.

Exploitation

Whether attackers are exploiting this vulnerability, and how likely they are to try in the next 30 days.

FIRST Exploit Prediction Scoring System (EPSS)About EPSS (opens in new tab)

FIRST's estimate of the chance attackers try to exploit this vulnerability in the next 30 days.

Probability of exploitationIt predicts attempts, not success, and is updated daily.
1.33%
Compared with other CVEs
At or above 71.794% of scored CVEs
Scored

Affected products

The products and versions with the vulnerability.

Listed by CNA

The products and versions affected, according to the organization that published this CVE.

VendorProductAffected versions
Medtronic2090 CareLink Programmer
  • All versions
Medtronic29901 Encore Programmer
  • All versions

How to fix the vulnerability, or reduce the risk until you can.

Workarounds

From ICS-CERT, which published this CVE.

Medtronic has assessed the vulnerabilities and determined that no new potential safety risks were identified. In order to enhance system security, Medtronic has added periodic integrity checks for files associated with the software deployment network. Additionally, Medtronic has developed server-side security changes that further enhance security. Medtronic reports that they will not be issuing a product update; however, Medtronic has identified compensating controls within this advisory to reduce the risk of exploitation and reiterates the following from the CareLink 2090 Programmer Reference Manual:

  • Maintain good physical controls over the programmer. Having a secure physical environment prevents access to the internals of the programmer.
  • Only connect the programmer to managed, secure networks.
  • Update the software on the programmer when Medtronic updates are available.
  • Alternatively, disconnect the programmer from the network. Network connectivity is not required for normal programmer operation.
  • Offline updates are available, contact your Medtronic representative for more information.

Medtronic has deployed mitigating patches to address the reported vulnerabilities. Medtronic has also stated that they have increased security controls associated with these vulnerabilities. As a result of the available mitigating patches, Medtronic has re-enabled the network-based software update mechanism.

Medtronic has stated that the patch for affected products can be obtained by contacting Medtronic Technical Services at 800‑638‑1991.

After additional review and risk evaluation of the affected products, Medtronic has disabled the network-based software update mechanism, including both the VPN and the HTTP subservices, as an immediate security mitigation. Users should not attempt to update the affected products over the network as this update mechanism is vulnerable to the attack described in section 4.2.3. Medtronic will continue to implement and deploy increased security protections and mitigations to address the vulnerabilities in this advisory.

Users should still obtain and apply updates via controlled USB dongles and should contact their Medtronic representative for more information.

Medtronic recommends that affected products continue to be used for their intended purpose in the previously described manner.

Medtronic has released a security bulletin for the 2090 CareLink Programmer https://www.medtronic.com/security .

Severity

How serious the vulnerability is if exploited, scored from 0 to 10 with the CVSS standard (opens in new tab).

  • 8 HighCVSS 3.0 · PrimaryPrimary scores are NVD's own. Secondary scores come from the organization that published the CVE, or from CISA. · Scored by NVD (opens in new tab)
    Attack vectorWhere the attacker has to be. Network is the widest: anywhere on the Internet.
    Adjacent network
    Attack complexityWhether the attack depends on conditions the attacker doesn't control.
    Low
    Privileges requiredThe access the attacker needs before attacking.
    Low
    User interactionWhether someone other than the attacker has to do something, like open a link.
    None
    ScopeWhether the attack can reach beyond the vulnerable component.
    Unchanged
    ConfidentialityHow much data the attacker can read.
    High
    IntegrityHow much data the attacker can change.
    High
    AvailabilityHow much the attacker can disrupt the system or service.
    High

    CVSS:3.0/AV:A/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:HView in FIRST's calculator (opens in new tab)

  • 7.1 HighCVSS 3.1 · SecondaryPrimary scores are NVD's own. Secondary scores come from the organization that published the CVE, or from CISA. · Scored by ICS-CERT (opens in new tab)
    Attack vectorWhere the attacker has to be. Network is the widest: anywhere on the Internet.
    Network
    Attack complexityWhether the attack depends on conditions the attacker doesn't control.
    High
    Privileges requiredThe access the attacker needs before attacking.
    Low
    User interactionWhether someone other than the attacker has to do something, like open a link.
    Required
    ScopeWhether the attack can reach beyond the vulnerable component.
    Unchanged
    ConfidentialityHow much data the attacker can read.
    High
    IntegrityHow much data the attacker can change.
    High
    AvailabilityHow much the attacker can disrupt the system or service.
    High

    CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:H/PR:L/UI:R/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:HView in FIRST's calculator (opens in new tab)

  • 5.2 MediumCVSS 2.0 · PrimaryPrimary scores are NVD's own. Secondary scores come from the organization that published the CVE, or from CISA. · Scored by NVD (opens in new tab)
    Attack vectorWhere the attacker has to be. Network is the widest: anywhere on the Internet.
    Adjacent network
    Attack complexityWhether the attack depends on conditions the attacker doesn't control.
    Low
    AuthenticationHow many times the attacker has to sign in.
    Single
    ConfidentialityHow much data the attacker can read.
    Partial
    IntegrityHow much data the attacker can change.
    Partial
    AvailabilityHow much the attacker can disrupt the system or service.
    Partial

    AV:A/AC:L/Au:S/C:P/I:P/A:PView in NVD's calculator (opens in new tab)

Weaknesses and attack patterns

The type of bug behind the vulnerability, and how attackers exploit that type.

  • Improper Restriction of Communication Channel to Intended Endpoints · CWE-923 (opens in new tab)

    The product establishes a communication channel to (or from) an endpoint for privileged or protected operations, but it does not properly ensure that it is communicating with the correct endpoint.

    Abstraction
    Class
    Mapping guidance
    Allowed with review
    Part of
  • Exposure of Sensitive Information to an Unauthorized Actor · CWE-200 (opens in new tab)

    The product exposes sensitive information to an actor that is not explicitly authorized to have access to that information.

    Likelihood of exploitHow likely MITRE rates attacks on this type of weakness, in general rather than for this vulnerability.
    High
    Abstraction
    Class
    Mapping guidance
    Discouraged
    Part of

References

Advisories, patches, exploits and more about this vulnerability.

This product uses the NVD API but is not endorsed or certified by the NVD (opens in new tab). CVE records from the CVE List (opens in new tab), weakness types from MITRE's CWE (opens in new tab)™ and attack patterns from its CAPEC (opens in new tab)™ are © The MITRE Corporation, used under the CVE (opens in new tab), CWE (opens in new tab) and CAPEC (opens in new tab) terms of use. Known exploited vulnerabilities and SSVC assessments are from CISA. Exploit predictions are from FIRST's EPSS (opens in new tab). About this data