Rockwell Automation ControlLogix PLC Improper Authentication

CVE-2012-6437

Assigned byThe organization (CNA) that assigned this CVE ID and published the record, usually the vendor.
ICS-CERT (opens in new tab)
Published
Last modified
NVD status
Modified
CVSS 2.010High

Description

The device does not properly authenticate users and the potential exists for a remote user to upload a new firmware image to the Ethernet card, whether it is a corrupt or legitimate firmware image. Successful exploitation of this vulnerability could cause loss of availability, integrity, and confidentiality and a disruption in communications with other connected devices.

Rockwell Automation EtherNet/IP products; 1756-ENBT, 1756-EWEB, 1768-ENBT, and 1768-EWEB communication modules; CompactLogix L32E and L35E controllers; 1788-ENBT FLEXLogix adapter; 1794-AENTR FLEX I/O EtherNet/IP adapter; ControlLogix 18 and earlier; CompactLogix 18 and earlier; GuardLogix 18 and earlier; SoftLogix 18 and earlier; CompactLogix controllers 19 and earlier; SoftLogix controllers 19 and earlier; ControlLogix controllers 20 and earlier; GuardLogix controllers 20 and earlier; and MicroLogix 1100 and 1400

Exploitation

Whether attackers are exploiting this vulnerability, and how likely they are to try in the next 30 days.

CISA SSVC assessmentAbout SSVC (opens in new tab)

CISA's assessment of whether it's exploited, whether attacks can be automated and how much control an attacker gains.

ExploitationWhether CISA has seen exploit code or attacks for this vulnerability.
None known
AutomatableWhether attackers can exploit it at scale without manual steps.
Yes
Technical impactHow much control of the affected system an attacker gains.
Full control
Assessed

FIRST Exploit Prediction Scoring System (EPSS)About EPSS (opens in new tab)

FIRST's estimate of the chance attackers try to exploit this vulnerability in the next 30 days.

Probability of exploitationIt predicts attempts, not success, and is updated daily.
10.532%
Compared with other CVEs
At or above 95.868% of scored CVEs
Scored

Affected products

The products and versions with the vulnerability.

Listed by CNA

The products and versions affected, according to the organization that published this CVE.

VendorProductAffected versions
Rockwell Automation1756-ENBT, 1756-EWEB, 1768-ENBT, 1768-EWEB communication modules
  • All versions
Rockwell AutomationCompactLogix L32E and L35E controllers
  • All versions
Rockwell Automation1788-ENBT FLEXLogix adapter
  • All versions
Rockwell Automation1794-AENTR FLEX I/O EtherNet/IP adapter
  • All versions
Rockwell AutomationControlLogix, CompactLogix, GuardLogix, and SoftLogix
  • ≤ 18
Rockwell AutomationCompactLogix and SoftLogix controllers
  • ≤ 19
Rockwell AutomationControlLogix and GuardLogix controllers
  • ≤ 20
Rockwell AutomationMicroLogix
  • 1100
  • 1400

Listed by NVD

The CPE names vulnerability scanners match, including products that bundle the affected software.

VendorProductTypeVulnerable versions
rockwellautomation1756-ewebHardware
  • All versions
rockwellautomation1768-enbtHardware
  • All versions
rockwellautomation1768-ewebHardware
  • All versions
rockwellautomationcompactlogixHardware
  • ≤ 18
rockwellautomationcompactlogix controllersHardware
  • ≤ 19
rockwellautomationcompactlogix l32e controllerHardware
  • All versions
rockwellautomationcompactlogix l35e controllerHardware
  • All versions
rockwellautomationcontrollogixHardware
  • ≤ 18
rockwellautomationcontrollogix controllersApplication
  • ≤ 20
rockwellautomationflexlogix 1788-enbt adapterHardware
  • All versions
1–10 of 14

How to fix the vulnerability, or reduce the risk until you can.

Solutions

From ICS-CERT, which published this CVE.

According to Rockwell, any of the above products that become affected by a vulnerability can be reset by rebooting or power cycling the affected product. After the reboot, the affected product may require some reconfiguration.

To mitigate the vulnerabilities, Rockwell has developed and released security patches on July 18, 2012, to address each of the issues. To download and install the patches please refer to Rockwell’s Advisories at:

https://rockwellautomation.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/470154
https://rockwellautomation.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/aid/470155
https://rockwellautomation.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/aid/470156

For more information on security with Rockwell Automation products, please refer to Rockwell’s Security Advisory Index http://rockwellautomation.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/54102 .

Workarounds

From ICS-CERT, which published this CVE.

Rockwell recommends updating to the newest firmware patches to fix the vulnerabilities, but if not able to do so right away, then Rockwell advises immediately employing the following mitigations for each of the affected products.

To mitigate the vulnerability with the Web server password authentication mechanism:

  • Upgrade the MicroLogix 1400 firmware to FRN 12 or higher.

  • Because of limitations in the MicroLogix 1100 platform, none of the firmware updates will be able to fix this issue, so users should use the following techniques to help reduce the likelihood of compromise.

  • Where possible, disable the Web server and change all default Administrator and Guest passwords.

  • If Web server functionality is needed, then Rockwell recommends upgrading the product’s firmware to the most current version to have the newest enhanced protections available such as: * When a controller receives two consecutive invalid authentication requests from an HTTP client, the controller resets the Authentication Counter after 60 minutes.

  • When a controller receives 10 invalid authentication requests from any HTTP client, it will not accept any valid or invalid authentication packets until a 24-hour HTTP Server Lock Timer timeout.

  • If Web server functionality is needed, Rockwell also recommends configuring user accounts to have READ only access to the product so those accounts cannot be used to make configuration change
    In addition to the above, Rockwell recommends concerned customers remain vigilant and continue to follow security strategies that help reduce risk and enhance overall control system security. Where possible, they suggest you apply multiple recommendations and complement this list with your own best-practices:

  • Employ layered security and defense-in-depth methods in system design to restrict and control access to individual products and control networks. Refer to http://www.ab.com/networks/architectures.html for comprehensive information about implementing validated architectures designed to deliver these measures.

  • Restrict physical and electronic access to automation products, networks, and systems to only those individuals authorized to be in contact with control system equipment.

  • Employ firewalls with ingress/egress filtering, intrusion detection/prevention systems, and validate all configurations. Evaluate firewall configurations to ensure other appropriate inbound and outbound traffic is blocked.

  • Use up-to-date end-point protection software (e.g., antivirus/antimalware software) on all PC-based assets.

  • Make sure that software and control system device firmware is patched to current releases.

  • Periodically change passwords in control system components and infrastructure devices.

  • Where applicable, set the controller key-switch/mode-switch to RUN mode.

For more information on security with Rockwell Automation products, please refer to Rockwell’s Security Advisory Index http://rockwellautomation.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/54102 .

Severity

How serious the vulnerability is if exploited, scored from 0 to 10 with the CVSS standard (opens in new tab).

  • 10 HighCVSS 2.0 · PrimaryPrimary scores are NVD's own. Secondary scores come from the organization that published the CVE, or from CISA. · Scored by NVD (opens in new tab)
    Attack vectorWhere the attacker has to be. Network is the widest: anywhere on the Internet.
    Network
    Attack complexityWhether the attack depends on conditions the attacker doesn't control.
    Low
    AuthenticationHow many times the attacker has to sign in.
    None
    ConfidentialityHow much data the attacker can read.
    Complete
    IntegrityHow much data the attacker can change.
    Complete
    AvailabilityHow much the attacker can disrupt the system or service.
    Complete

    AV:N/AC:L/Au:N/C:C/I:C/A:CView in NVD's calculator (opens in new tab)

  • 9.8 CriticalCVSS 3.1 · SecondaryPrimary scores are NVD's own. Secondary scores come from the organization that published the CVE, or from CISA. · Scored by CISA (opens in new tab)
    Attack vectorWhere the attacker has to be. Network is the widest: anywhere on the Internet.
    Network
    Attack complexityWhether the attack depends on conditions the attacker doesn't control.
    Low
    Privileges requiredThe access the attacker needs before attacking.
    None
    User interactionWhether someone other than the attacker has to do something, like open a link.
    None
    ScopeWhether the attack can reach beyond the vulnerable component.
    Unchanged
    ConfidentialityHow much data the attacker can read.
    High
    IntegrityHow much data the attacker can change.
    High
    AvailabilityHow much the attacker can disrupt the system or service.
    High

    CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:HView in FIRST's calculator (opens in new tab)

  • 10 HighCVSS 2.0 · SecondaryPrimary scores are NVD's own. Secondary scores come from the organization that published the CVE, or from CISA. · Scored by ICS-CERT (opens in new tab)
    Attack vectorWhere the attacker has to be. Network is the widest: anywhere on the Internet.
    Network
    Attack complexityWhether the attack depends on conditions the attacker doesn't control.
    Low
    AuthenticationHow many times the attacker has to sign in.
    None
    ConfidentialityHow much data the attacker can read.
    Complete
    IntegrityHow much data the attacker can change.
    Complete
    AvailabilityHow much the attacker can disrupt the system or service.
    Complete

    AV:N/AC:L/Au:N/C:C/I:C/A:CView in NVD's calculator (opens in new tab)

Weaknesses and attack patterns

The type of bug behind the vulnerability, and how attackers exploit that type.

  • Improper Authentication · CWE-287 (opens in new tab)

    When an actor claims to have a given identity, the product does not prove or insufficiently proves that the claim is correct.

    Likelihood of exploitHow likely MITRE rates attacks on this type of weakness, in general rather than for this vulnerability.
    High
    Abstraction
    Class
    Mapping guidance
    Discouraged
    Part of

References

Advisories, patches, exploits and more about this vulnerability.

This product uses the NVD API but is not endorsed or certified by the NVD (opens in new tab). CVE records from the CVE List (opens in new tab), weakness types from MITRE's CWE (opens in new tab)™ and attack patterns from its CAPEC (opens in new tab)™ are © The MITRE Corporation, used under the CVE (opens in new tab), CWE (opens in new tab) and CAPEC (opens in new tab) terms of use. Known exploited vulnerabilities and SSVC assessments are from CISA. Exploit predictions are from FIRST's EPSS (opens in new tab). About this data